Down to 4lbs of a crisp break. Have 2 of the 12rd and the original 10rd mags with grip extenders. Dan and Jeremy could ask for recommendations, pick the top 40, and do a 10 article series. Most versatile when it comes to upgrades or swapping between models. Taurus G2 and G3 arent micro-compacts. I would have liked to have rented and shot both before I made my decision but the Sig was not widely available. Grrrr. The Hellcat is also a subcompact 9mm pistol, but it is slightly larger than the P938. I would put on them or above the level the Glock, Glock has been resting on their laurels for a couple of decades. Since the Sig is the real O.G., itll go first: So as you can see, the Sig is a little shorter overall and weighs a little less, while the Hellcat is a little shorter height-wise. Hated the narrow slide to Grip space and the hulky slide lock. To me that is the ultimate complimant to give a concealed carry piece. Impressive. Got it on sale for a little under $700 with the red dot included. I am wondering if the trigger is the same now on the Max 9? . The trigger pull is between 5.5 and 7.5 pounds. Capacity certainly is a plus. Lets take a look at the two side-by-side and see what they have to offer. So you like how the P365 looks from behind? The slide has front and rear serrations for easy manipulation. Size: The Springfield 911 is a little bit smaller than the Sig P938. He loves it. The Hellcats tritium front sight with bright green outline is great a lot like the P365s. If youre looking for a smaller gun thats easy to shoot, the P938 is the better option. The Hellcat is a very small gun, making it a good choice for concealed carry. However the Nano, I could have gone on all day. I go to my local range about twice a month (once a month since Septembe of 2020, when the ammo shortage really hit locally). The Sig and Rugers are great. The clip holds six rounds, and you can get another round in the chamber for the traditional 6+1 setup. Its an extremely easy micro-compact to shoot well. What it doesnt have, though, is the best slide serrations even if they might look the niftiest. So far she loves it. I owned a PF9 and currently own two LC9s pistols. The P365s sights are the same but a little lower profile. While the front is undeniably easy and fast to pick up, it just doesnt snag my eye as well as the front sight on the P365 and Hellcat. Copyright 2022 | Gun Digest | All Rights Reserved. I've enjoyed it, no issues, shoots relatively accurate considering it's size, I just always wanted more capacity. Ultimately, I came close. The Shield Plus is markedly flatter and softer shooting than the other three pistols in this roundup, and the larger grip circumference and curvier shape provide tons of confidence and control. I don't have trouble with magazines corroding, but I live in Southwest Colorado where relative humidity is very low, so that may have something to do with the corrosion issue. It just feels so perfect in the hand. Inspired from the tv series Yellowstone, this Kelly Reilly Blue Coat is poncho-style outerwear. The longer summary is that I went from 13 rounds carried with a reload to 23, a significant increase, with about the same space and weight. Small guns like this are not precision pistolsnot even a little bit. Competition is good, though, and the P365 currently has a butt load in that arena. Dan has put a ton of rounds through this Hellcat and it has proven itself reliable and easy to carry. Per the Max 9 review, do I need a rail tie to disassemble any of these or just the Ruger? Lets start with the rails. This makes it easy to grip the slide and work it at a variety of angles. Snappy little sucker. The Hellcat is a 9mm, which is a good all-around caliber for self-defense. I ran a couple of these guns side by side shooting the Nano and nothing compared after 200 rds. 803K views 3 years ago #TFBTV In this episode of TFBTV, James Reeves reviews the new Springfield Hellcat and compares it to the SIG P365. Any money spent on firearms will be for magazines. Thanks to the larger grip circumference and different shape of the Hellcats grip, it feels and shoots like its larger than the P365 even if ones pinky is wrapped under the mag. Its too unreliable for a CCW. Id put it head-to-head with a GLOCK 19, for instance, and I expect most shooters would outperform on speed and accuracy with the Shield Plus. I have looked at and briefly fired the Hellcat but I think the SIG is a much better quality weapon. We'll send you the latest guides and training tips geared Most of us wont. Still, its a half inch shorter and about 0.2 inches skinnier than most of the smaller sub-compacts out there, so I think its fair to say it still clearly belongs right here in the micro-compact category. Like oddball ammo loads, as things return to a newer normal a lot of small lot manufacturing will hit the wayside while makers attempt to completely supply the bigger sellers. Your email address will not be published. None developed problems over time and usage did not help or hurt the problems. Select what level shooter you are! Sig brings a 5.25-pound trigger pull, while the Hellcat offers a 6-pound, 10-ounce trigger pull. As mentioned, the sig p938 barrel length is 3.1-inches, which is slightly short than the 3.41-inches of the Glock 43X. Soyes, I now feel a draw to replace that image but I also feel like doing so would be giving validity to a false narrative and surrendering to dirty politics. The Diamondback was a bit much in the recoil department, the 640 limited the round count to five, and the 380 is a 380. Considering that the last few times we've done videos on individual micro compact carry guns we get comments asking for opinions on some of the less well-known options, we decided to speed run 5. The introductory photo points counter-clockwise and is level. Its worth mentioning that the Hellcat remains slightly shorter but also packs one extra round in its 11-round magazine. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sXldafIl5DQ keep em coming. For pocket carry, my choice would be a Springfield 911 9mm or Sig P938. Possibly a Hellcat to achieve higher capacity, but I have yet to see one. It is small and lightweight, making it easy to carry. Wouldnt expect a blog to create a compendium of every handgun commercially available for purchase, so some will naturally not receive attention. I like it. The MAX-9 knocks it out of the park on performance per dollar. For me, the P365 shoots straighter even at 25 yards, I can consistently land fast and consistent shots onto a gong. I have a KelTec P10 ( SCCY Twin) and the Taurus G2 Subcompact is in a ( superior) league of its own compare to that guns and the others you referenced. Dont buy any of them. Both the P365 and Hellcat conceal very easily without any major differences between the two. My grandfather fought in WWII (https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/my-grandfathers-1943-union-switch-signal-m1911a1/). Also try https://techcrachi.com/sling-tv-free-trial/. I bought a S&W 4566 a while back, 1990s vintage, dead night sites got white model car paint and will not get $150 spend on replacements to light them up. At an MSRP of just $499 (and when the market gets back to normal its going to retail for substantially less than the other three pistols) it includes the optics-ready slide and the tritium-illuminated fiber optic front sight. Holy heck is it short and crisp with an insanely short, crisp reset as well. My usual EDC is the Hellcat. Compare them all you want; I have no need for a micro-compact. Ive never thought of the M&Ps serrations as sub-par or anything, and theyre without a doubt plenty functional and nothing I would normally complain about, but in this heads-up comparison they simply dont compete on the same level as the P365s and MAX-9s. For my Max 9 I just snap the pin catch lever down, hold the slide at the point where the pin comes out with the pin exit facing down, and gently tap it on the cleaning mat, and it falls right out. On a related note; all of the reviews Ive watched/read on the Shield Plus (outside of this one) measured the trigger between 4.5 and 5.5 lbs. All that said, Id be remiss not to mention that the SIG SAUER P365 was the first to accomplish this feat only if you dont count the KELTEC P11, which was released in 1995 and would absolutely belong in this group were it not discontinued in 2019. One thing to consider is that the 365 can be had for smidge under $400 dollars these days, so oddly the Sig is currently the value leader between the two. The most important factor to consider when choosing a concealed carry gun is its size. Just the Ruger. There are pros and cons to both options and it really depends on what you are looking for in a sub-ohm tank. For instance, my early P365 here has a slightly better trigger than my P365XL, which was made two years later. However, I have probably a thousand rounds out of both guns. Style has a place and this newer gun at least looks more duty grade with no obtrusive committee think or Grip Zone molded into it. Which would you carry? Additionally, this bad boy has the best trigger of the bunch. I have shot the Sig and it is very popular at the range. The Keltec PF9 is lighter and thinner by a lot. The tapered shape of the Shield Plus grip as it transitions from rounded palm swells down to a somewhat sharply rounded or tapered backstrap sets it apart in this group. Springfield Hellcat vs Sig P365 (with pictures) | Clinger Holsters. Even that one almost got traction before the DB finally backed off. towards your level. It provides more grip and control than appearances might suggest, yet it wont scratch up or overly irritate the tender princess skin on your hip. So ultimately it was an easy decision. Springfields Hellcat uses a flat-faced trigger. Got the Hellcat when I could find one with at that time one of the two optics that were available. I find the Max9 to be a vastly superior shooter over the 365 in terms of recoil management, and the optics ready slide is a big plus. I also have the P11 keltec and it should not be even mentioned with the others. Dont believe the Keltec trash talkers, Ive owned four different Keltaec models and theyre all accurate and reliable. Subscribe to Pew Pew Tactical's sales and deals email. With drills like Dot Torture and the iHack, I tend to drop rounds with the Hellcat, but less so with the Sig. Hellcat stays a little ahead until you get to the 15-round magazines. It weighs only 18.3 ounces with an empty magazine. Sig Sauer P365 or Springfield Armory Hellcat? The only downside is that it doesnt have night sights like the Hellcat. More of these type reviews and reports !! Possibly a Hellcat to achieve higher capacity, but I have yet to see one. Haven't had the opportunity to check out a Hellcat. The sights offer the starkest contrast between the two pistols. Get Our Top Shooting Drills and Zeroing Targets ($47 value - but FREE for a limited time). Tie an arms length of paracord to the trigger guard and swing it around Ninja style. The Hellcat is equipped with a trigger safety and a manual safety. And I never want to return to the Light Crisp Triggers. The Taurus is only a little bit bigger than those four, feels great in the hand, and will be much easier to conceal and carry than our blocky Springfield XD and XDm, which was our one major requirement for this purchase. The Taurus is even farther off. Jeremy strives to collect objective data whenever possible, and looks to write accurate reviews that reflect the true user experience. I dont accept the practice of woke upper class white folk attempting to tell people from various minority groups what should or shouldnt insult or scare them. So, if you are looking for a gun with more features, the Hellcat may be worth the extra cost. Without a question I shoot the Shield Plus a little bit better again, it shoots like a compact but itsjust enough larger and heavier and Ive become so familiar and used to my P365 that its still my choice. If you're wondering which of these small pistols to buy, read this review. I like the LC9S with the slim design and like the grip. About | It is lightweight and has a very small footprint. Shooting the PF9 is like taking bad tasting medicine. The Sig P938 and the Hellcat are both 9mm pistols that are popular among gun enthusiasts. For more carry guns, check out our comprehensive list of the Best Concealed Carry Guns. JavaScript is disabled. I took a pass because the people who had bought them were immediately dumping them. Drag/drop and reorder the handguns to compare on top of eachother, New handguns and the best gun and ammo deals straight to your inbox, SAO Subcompact Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger, Striker-Fired Subcompact Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger. In all fairness, I haven't shot one, but the gun just feels topheavy to me. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. No RDS, not light or laser. And I know it exists, because I have one. mag (have 3 of them) thus a longer grip. The on-going maintenance of guns (or people) almost always exceeds the initial acquisition price. The Hellcat has a polymer frame and a stainless steel slide, and it comes with tritium night sights. The most popular models are the 9mm and .45 ACP versions, but you can also find .380 ACP and .22 LR versions. My LGS made the remark that since the 365 hit the market the 938 was marked down by SIG to counteract its sales going soft. Probably Sig P365. I was there when Jeremy arranged the guns for that photo and neither of us saw anything wrong with it. I specifically mentioned the Daily Beast for a reason. The Glock 26 is bigger in every dimension and still only holds 10 rounds in its flush-fitting magazine. Never forget that Gatson Glock is a old plastic expert that made fine curtain rods. Wouldve loved to get any one of those four, but in the end we decided that our budget didnt stretch up to a circa-$500 pistol and got a Taurus G2C instead for half the price. Its fabricated outrage for political gain perpetrated by one group of highly privileged people white knighting on the alleged behalf of some other group. And I didnt see the allegedly evil image until some of you pointed it out. The Hornady is also my go to, but there is none to be had right now, so conservation of current stock rules. Havent held the Ruger but it seems like a best buy for the dough. Did I mention the 365 is a real slab side slide, vs the channeled and relieved 938? Copyright 2023 Pew Pew Media, Inc. All rights reserved. The 365 trigger is one which I would most definitely use with a safety. P365X: Standard length slide with the longer XL grip and optics ready capability. No plans getting any of them. Wheres the Glock 43x (capable of 15 rounds in a similar size) or the Taurus G3C which is optics ready and feature rich? I expect that will change once the new wears off. This can be a bit of a drawback if youre in a self-defense situation, as it takes an extra step to prepare the gun for firing. Were I not Jewish Id be more afraid of criticism of the lead photo, stupid and misplaced as it would still be, but since Im actually in the group that would be aggrieved were this photo any sort of a problem its even easier for me to stand behind its entirely uncontroversial and inoffensive status. For something to slip in my pocket I have a SCCY CPX-1 and CPX-2.. You must log in or register to reply here. To me it doesnt feel as good in my hands and as mentioned in the article, the sights just are not as precise as the 365. Specifications: Springfield Armory Hellcat 9mm Pistol Height: 4 (flush magazine), 4.5 (extended magazine) Barrel Length: 3 Overall Length: 6 Width: 1 Capacity: 11+1 (flush magazine), 13+1 (extended magazine) Weight: 17.9 ounces It feels like a competition trigger. Copyright @2023 TigerDroppings.com. Both are textured and plenty easy to use. I will stick with the soft shooting Nano. They're really handy. No experience with the Hellcat but if capacity is an issue, I'd look harder at it. My go to for every day carry is the Sig P365xl with the Wilson Combat grip module. I also never brought up the fact the P365 and Hellcat had reliability issues from release, thats not very inspiring for a gun you are going to carry everyday. So, you trade it in. To summarize that, I sold the P938. So he shows me his advance release (he is a Sig dealer) of the P365. It is one of the newest pistols on the market and has already gained a loyal following. It weighs just under a pound, making it a very lightweight and easy to carry option. Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting. Ignore the previous comment, Im a dumbass and you did mention it. Sigs XRAY3 sights mix day and night time sights. Great guns. Just so happens that theyre very good guns and I think the problems at release were overblown in terms of how pervasive they were. I got it to what I consider the perfect carry gun for me in the Florida heat. I believe its a more welcoming community than almost any other group that rallies behind any other cause, and this belief is based on my experience being with this group at events and conferences and conventions and on hunting trips and training sessions and whatever else for nearly a decade. The large magazine release is easy to use, but not so tall that it risks accidental activation. They vary slightly in shape but arent much different. It weighs just 11.5 ounces, while the Sig P938 weighs 16 ounces. Hellcat OSP: Standard model with a 3-inch barrel and 11-round magazine, but is optics ready. There has been some variability in P365 trigger pull quality. Its just too square for me. Getting sight focus with either isnt tough to do and getting lead on target quickly isnt tough to do either. The P938 also has a manual safety, which some shooters prefer. It also by FAR the best shooter out of the three I have shot. Even with the 15 rd. However, it doesn't include the best Hellcat model of all, the Pro OSP! May replace my Walther PPQ with a P365 Macro! It has a low-profile sights that are easy to conceal, and it has a very short trigger pull that makes it easy to fire accurately. Which one should you choose? The backstrap, as sharply rounded as it is, isnt as comfortable as the backstrap of the P365 as it focuses its force in a more distinct vertical line across my palm, but I love how functional it is. From a practical standpoint it was probably the best weapons purchase I ever made. Lastly, if you are going to be regularly exposing the weapon to harsh conditions, the P938 is more durable. Shield Plus mags are listed at brownells at 41.99 x 10 mags = $420. Yeah. Two whole ounces more? The P365s slide serrations are plenty sufficient, but the Hellcat outshines them. Another important factor to consider is the guns caliber. Put a full-size gun on layaway & got 2 range passes at Point Blank. SIG's X-RAY3 sights are fantastic . Im not a dedicated convert to optics on pistols, but I have a Holosun 507k on the Max 9 and it seems to be a good combo. Tactical Development rail, Viridian C5L Laser/Light with auto activation, and a Holoson 507, and 15rd mag backup. Dark. The wife and I both have Springfields as our primary carry pieces. The longer slide makes little difference for CC and the WC grip module, with a 12 rd flush mag, is much superior, in my experience, to the standard P365 of P365x grip module. Premium Concealed Carry Holsters Search by Gun IWB Holsters OWB Holsters Revolver Accessories Instructions About Blog FAQ's Contact Us New In Store Contender 4.80 Dark Wing Left Hand Canik TP9SFx Review Search by Gun Canik Canik TP9SF IWB Holsters OWB Holsters Revolver In fact, if my P365 broke tomorrow, Id have no reservations about carrying the Hellcat, though. In a competition stage wed both shoot the Shield Plus. Theres no question whatsoever that Rugers new MAX-9 represents the best value of the pack. The Hellcat is slightly more efficient when it comes to ammunition capacity. The Shields slide serrations are fine. Wrong size category. The Sig will not and the Croatian made Springfield I just would not buy. I usually buy one box of my preferred carry ammo, Hornady Critical Duty 135 gr +P, a month to cycle, on top of handloaded target rounds, but since Sept. 2020, Im just running target ammo. Funny, after all this time, the best shooting for me is the Beretta Nano. No optics, no compensators, no long barrels, just the two most common variants of these guns. But which one is the best for you? I own my second P365, traded my original for one with a safety, with a 12 rd magazine which fits my hand perfectly. The Hellcat has a fixed white dot front sight and a U-notch rear sight. Pick the type action you want. I still use it tho.. use it with https://amzn.to/38VqIUy mags, Useful article. If you are looking for a concealed carry weapon, the SIG P365 is a great option. good after a fluff and buff on the reliability front, and accurate. On paper, hardly a difference. We already have an account registered for email address (, We noticed that you have previously logged in with your, Check what do you get by creating an account, Bookmark and compare your favorite firearms. True but you have to switch out the baseplate unless you want to leave a gap when using the 15 round magazine configured for the Xl when using the shorter 365. As pointed out in other comments below, if you compare it to the hateful symbol the arms of this pistol arrangement point the wrong direction, it isnt canted 45 degrees, etc etc. I got the two 10 rounders with it and also bought a 12 for the carried reload. There are a few things to consider when deciding whether to purchase a Hellcat or a SIG P365. A Azmarlin39a Elite So, which is the better option? We'll only use the information provided according to our privacy policy. I'm a P365 Fan. Excellent. Every single one of these pistols is reliable, accurate, and easy to conceal. For me, the flat trigger is preferred over the curved trigger. Pull weight is exactly what I prefer in a carry gun: about 5 pounds. Dan, the people pointing to the photo are likely concerned that the anti-gun mob will have a quick victory, shouting that POTG/TTAG are using the photo as a secret declaration of being neo-nazis. Agreed . I carry with Hornady 115 Critical Defense. Safety: Sig Sauer P365 SAS. This is a comparison and when you compare back-to-back the difference is meaningful. The P938 is a smaller gun, making it more comfortable to carry. The size and weight specs more or less tell the story of how these four pistols compare on paper, though there is some nuance that cant be seen or felt in these figures. All rights reserved. They are designed for the traditional 15 yards or so concealed carry range. I find the P365 to be jumpy and I really have to concentrate to shoot accurately. Learn the 3 most popular shooting stances & more. And stay in touch with newsletters of our best articles on techniques, guns, & gear. Love the grip ergonomics on them. Even the Taurus PT111 G2 is comparable. Its remarkable, really, to pack so much into such small pistols. Best not to give the other side any ammunition if we can help it, but at some point youve got to draw a line and take a damn the torpedoes approach, because they will twist EVERYTHING you do or say. Ive also owned just one s&w polymer pistol, an original m&p 9 pro, with around 25,000 rounds through it. Youre an equal. 365 just felt like much more quality gun. Sig Sauer P938, Sig Sauer 1911 Emperor Fastback Scorpion Carry, Sig Sauer P227 Sig Sauer P226 TACOPS, Sig Sauer P229 Scorpion ELITE, Sig Sauer M11-A1, Sig Sauer P365, P365XL . What you do notice is more muzzle flip than the other guns. The pull is considerably heavier than the P365 but far from bad. Wasnt much difference, but the Hornady feels a little stouter to me. Its about an inch shorter and half an inch narrower. If capacity is the issue Sig offers a 15 round magazine that is interchangeable between the p365 and p365 xl. Im not going to list starting cost for guns when it only applies to like 0.3% of the people who buy them and it includes hundreds of dollars in completely optional products, though. The sig is a fantastic little gun that shoots well and stays on target well for follow up, and the day night sights are easy to acquire. Overall its controls, including its takedown method, are the most difficult to use of the four guns. Consider your needs and make the decision that is right for you. If you are going to be carrying a good bit at night, the included night sights of the P938 are a nice feature, but night sights can easily be added to any weapon. And I didnt see the allegedly evil image until some of you pointed it out.. They will only go dead again. For an MSRP premium of just $30, youd be silly not to buy the optics-ready Hellcat. Its noticeable and its worth mentioning when these pistols are specifically designed to be as skinny, short, and lightweight as they can be. On the other hand, the frontstrap is where the shooters fingers do most of their gripping, and the lower toe of the P365 allows my mens size large hands to place precisely half a pinky firmly on the frontstrap. Ive owned my SIG P365 since mid 2018, so Im coming up on 3 years. P365XL manual safety is my EDC. Not any worse than using a 33-rd stick in a Glock 26. The first trip to the range was the real eye opener. Trigger pull might be an issue, but the sights might be an issue as well. I have carried and practiced with my 365sas for over 18 months and I like the feel of the gun and how it seems to naturally point. In general, I figure the most expensive thing is probably ammo (especially now), then mags, then the difference in price of the gun. The P365 SAS is all about being low profile with the flush-mount FT Bullseye sight, while the Hellcat OSP sacrifices a bit of concealment ease with dual sighting optionsthe iron sights and miniature reflex sight. I mean, they rust super easily. The Taurus G2 and G3 are noticably larger than these guns. This is where mistakes are made with the 1911 a subcompact .45ACP with short slide and higher cycling speeds using a standard 1911 mag means issues. So off to the store we go and I had the 365 in mind. You say the Shield has the best serrations but that you havent even touched the Ruger, which objectively has the best slide serrations. Do you like the Sig? Both Hellcats had less then 200 rounds through them, that tells me something. There is a CZ micro I would like to try but of all the ones I mentioned, none is as well made, none feels as good as my P365 though the HK has a softer recoil. In this case by website listing, except S&W, which I cant find on their website , p365 mags are listed at $49.99 x 10 magazines = $500 Shoehorning 10+ rounds into a skinny micro-compact was and certainly still is a fantastic recipe for sales success, and, as this very article shows, others have jumped into the fray.
Network Traffic Can Be Controlled In How Many Ways,
Vice Ganda Sister Marivic Viceral,
Fill In The Table Using This Function Rule Calculator,
Articles H