Rumer Cosmetic Surgery 105 Ardmore Ave Ardmore, PA 19003. It also alleged Dr. Rumer used pictures of another surgeons results, claiming them as her own. COLEY v. RUMER, 2:18-cv-01188 - CourtListener.com Patients of Rumer often have to undergo stressful and costly revision surgeries with other doctors. 24 Sep 2022 18:58:25 I've gained much of that weight since then, but it's too fucking late now. It's completely pointless. Her office is still open for business and she still performing surgeries for profit. Dr. Kathy L. Rumer is a board-certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon in the Philadelphia tri-state area who has deep experience with gender reassignment surgery and a practice that is geared exclusively toward transgender patients. Speaking out after a traumatic experience, in a moment when so few are able to access care, can be weaponized by anti-trans activists, GRS training can vary between a week of observation with an established surgeon to a years-long apprenticeship program, If the patient survived the operationand doesnt die of some hideous complication or is not readmitted multiple times, that is their measure of success., Each of the plaintiffs Described issues characterized as permanent injury such that the plaintiffs would never have sexual function again. (650) 570-2270. Complaint. Express your first amendment right and let them know what you think. An anti-trans campaigner named Walt Heyer, according to several people involved, acquired notes from the meeting between patients and the hospital under false pretenses, promising legal help and support for detransitioning to one of the complainants. Like. She says she initially turned to Reddit to post about her experience with Dr. Rumer, but then trans exclusionary radical feminists (TERFs) ended up sharing her post in the GenderCritical sub-reddit, a recently banned forum that had become ground zero for TERF rhetoric. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Are You a Graphic Designer? It doesnt really look like a vulva. Even other doctors, they say, will end up at least once trying to stick a finger in my urethra because its not obvious., Rose says that Dr. Rumer didnt construct a clitoral hood, leaving their clitoris completely exposed to irritation. Imagine trying to run your surgical clinic and instead of getting calls for consultations you instead get angry calls regarding your continued support of a transphobic doctor. Here is Mazzonis number, call them up and ask them why they wont denounce Rumer and continue to refer patients to her further endangering the community they claim to provide safe gender affirming care to. She told me I needed surgery under "twilight sedation" to fix much deeper granulation tissue. Worse yet, her help came from some of the very people we are supposed to trust . I had no idea about this until a friend told me. The Butcher of Ardmore has continued for long enough. The organization runs its own surgical trainings, which began under Greens presidency from 2014 to 2016. This has been an extremely traumatizing experience for me. Kathy Rumer completely botched this abdominal flap phalloplasty + vaginectomy. A revision procedure with a different surgeon was unsuccessful in repairing Dr. Rumers initial work, even causing additional issues, and Simpson was left without a clitoris. That's my layperson understanding of this. Copy and paste it, mirror it, etc. Our sisters at Stonewall would have never accepted Rumer or her allies and neither should we. Rumer falls short in some terrifying waysblaming the patients for their surgical complications, anger and hostility towards those who complain, lack of availability or accountability. Dr. Rumer, she adds, also understands the vulnerability of patients who desperately desire surgery in a climate of still relatively few surgeons.. Something like cardiac surgery or plastic surgery has., When I asked Green about the varying quality of standards in the current landscape, he told me it was because of our medical system: Its because of the decades of anti-trans bias that has existed, he said. Crozer Chester Medical Center 1 Medical Center Blvd Chester, PA 19013. There is so much more to this story, but I'm moving on. Worse yet, Lake is possibly getting kickbacks for every patient she refers to Rumer. They went to all these conferences and stuff essentially to do marketing promotion of their work, says Green. I also quite possibly need a lawyer. I have a mystery wound hole. Write to: The Honorable Jamie Raskin, Chairman, Subcommittee on Civil Rights and Civil Liberties 2242 Rayburn HOB, Washington, D.C 20515. I'm still bleeding. Dr. Rumer was referring to World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, the organization that sets out guidelines and best practices for trans-related health worldwide. And according to Green, theres little incentive for university hospitals and other medical research centers to invest in research and training on trans-related health issues if the government could turn around tomorrow and end multiple funding sources on the whims of an ideologically driven political appointee. Rumers litigiousness isnt unique among surgeons, and the environment can make it difficult for many trans people to find recourse, or warn others about bad surgical experiences. Despite all of this Marci has remained mostly silent. Adam Sullivan, 42, runs a small and little-known political . Ask them all about their participation in this case. Often, patients rely completely on a surgeons self-reported data. Cis people generally associate transitioning with extensive surgeries, but transition-related surgical procedures are very rarely approved for trans people under age 18. Kathy Rumer is a top tier butcher i've heard horror stories of vaginas falling out of bodies and exploding due to her butchery . Carlie had just returned to Louisiana when she went to the movies with her girlfriend and had trouble sitting down comfortably. At this point, I can BARELY dilate. (THANK YOU!) We may earn a commission from links on this page. This means no city is safe from her reach. Shes been a member of WPATH since 2010. We all have complications, things dont always come out the way we want them to. So who is responsible for allowing a monster like Rumer to continue? Without that key element, insurance coverage questions are left to regional decision boards, often comprised of insurance company representatives and public health officials who may harbor anti-trans beliefs they want to institutionalize. Call 855-782-5665 for your consultation. Do not worry, direct action takes on many forms. On June 12, a newly finalized HHS rule which eliminated gender identity non-discrimination protections within the Affordable Care Act recently garnered over 200,000 public comments. In April, Dr. Rumers counsel attempted to subpoena me in an unrelated libel case, demanding I hand over all notes, emails, documents and research related to this story. Annoying the desk reps enough might actually get Mazzoni to finally speak up and say something about Rumer. I need a new surgeon. Cookie Notice Heyer disputes the claim that he obtained the notes under false pretenses, telling Jezebel his Federalist article ended up resulting in blowback against his source, who in turn declined legal help to avoid further conflict. A sub for the discussion of surgeries, surgery results, surgeon satisfaction and the costs incurred by transgender people. About 2 weeks before I was supposed to have revision surgery, Dr. Rumer's associate (or family member?) Show them what happens when you mess with a community that is used to fighting for their existence on a daily basis. In finding a doctor to perform a surgery prospective patients like Carlie are largely on their own. She has not pursued any official avenues of complaint, worried that doing so would make it less likely that another surgeon would take on her case. The two had spoken on Skype a few months before the surgery but never had an in-person pre-op appointment. They dont make themselves available for trainings. (He says the model combatted similar problems within bariatric surgery in the early 2000s, providing concrete outcome data and tightening restrictions on a surgery once struggling with similar issues.) Providing an Invaluable service to the trans community also means listening to the trans community, nothing for us, without us. The organization serves as an active gatekeeper, laying out strict guidelines for which patients are allowed access to transition-related surgical procedures, but it does not expressly oversee the practices that perform them. Over time, we have participated in several in-person meetings with individuals and groups. Stage a Picket: All of the individuals and organizations on the list have a physical place of business, nothing applies pressure more than a dozen people standing outside an office with a megaphone and signs and the first place that should be picketed is most definitely Rumers office in Ardmore. It's been too long. Once she woke up from the anesthesia, she was told that the procedure had taken twice as long as normal because her genitalia had been difficult to dissect. I CAN NOT STRESS THIS ENOUGH. Currently, I barely have a fucking vagina. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Rose says theyre still angry about their surgery six years later, and theyre concerned about Dr. Rumer operating on trans people. There is an open petition calling for Rumers resignation with 600+ signatures. Dr. Kathy Rumer, a reconstructive surgeon and aesthetician based in Philadelphia, agrees. In a follow-up appointment and then again in a subsequent email which Simpson shared with Jezebel, Dr. Rumer blamed the dead skin on a pair of too-tight Depends Simpson had worn in the hospital, which Simpson believes was a way to dodge the issue. Dr. Rumer, who has not treated the 65-year-old, added that "a botched rhinoplasty can lead to . Yeah, avoid Rumer; she's a butcher. Every other week there is a new horror account on Reddit where someone comes out who was victimized by this doctor in her genocide against the trans community. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. "Just to let you know posting nasty reviews on REDDIT is not a very kind thing to do when you are looking for help from my office." After learning of its existence, Carlie joked that shes a graphic designer by trade and if she had made the site it wouldnt look so shit.. Now I can only get half-way to the first dot on my smallest purple dilator. And even then, website administrators are sometimes nervous to host negative remarks against a specific surgeon, fearing a potential libel suit. Returning home from the movie back in Louisiana, Carlie took a closer look at her new vulva. According to a Jezebel article (which is predominantly about Rumer) It is next to impossible to hold doctors like Rumer accountable. He botched me and many others and killed a few. Comment. Infections occur, tissue necrosis, dehiscences, those things occur with any surgery, he says. In her state, some gender affirming surgeries are covered by the states Medicaid program, but with trans healthcare a political target for the Republican party, Danielle felt some urgency to have it done quickly back in 2015. Share The Following Links: Want to effectively spread the word and provide receipts of Rumers wrong doing? Protected by Google ReCAPTCHA. Share Dr. Its an institutional framework that doesnt fit the current challenges, says Green. The two had spoken on Skype a few months before the surgery but . Though she says her visual and sensorial results were good, Danielles experience in the hospital left much to be desired. Recent attempts to quantify the learning curve for vaginoplasty have indicated that 40 procedures need to be performed to truly learn the technique. The subpoena demanded I turn over all notes, emails, documents and research referencing Dr. Rumer or her practice. 24 Sep 2022 19:13:22 Oct 2020 - 1-year update: Kathy (or someone from her staff) found this post and emailed me to complain about it only 20 days after it was posted (and after around 2 years of complications at that point). Insurance coverage often dictates where patients receive care, as it did for Danielle, a 42-year-old trans woman who lives in Portland, Oregon, and depends on Medicaid. Some anti-trans activists create opposition to access to trans-affirming care by claiming treatments are experimental or too risky to be ethical, another obstacle when patients consider speaking openly about their experiences with individual surgeons. Audrina Minto, also known as Arturo Minto, filed a complaint July 2 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Kathy Rumer has left a trail of almost unspeakable atrocities in her wake from patients who lost sensation to patients who have had the wall between their vagina and their rectal area torn. In the highly politicized world of gender-affirming surgery, answers about standard measures of care can be hard to find. Kathy Rumer is no ally of the trans community in a time when republicans are actively rolling back abortion and LGBTQ rights. Despite this, Rumer continues to dodge accountability for her actions, not only have a decades worth of complaints to medical boards, hospitals, and insurance companies fallen upon deaf ears, Dr. Rumer has had a total of four medical malpractice lawsuits against her, all of them resulting in a settlement. Schecter notes that postoperative travel and unclean or unsafe home environments may also contribute to complications, but ultimately its up to surgeons to counsel their patients and ensure these risk factors are minimized. According to several studies, the industry average for those complications range between 10 percent and 64 percent. The most active members of the group left, says Danielle, including herself and a dozen others. Dr. Kathy Rumer - Gender Reassignment Surgery Expert According to a complaint submitted to the Pennsylvania State Medical Board and shared with Jezebel, Dr. Rumer allegedly claimed a 1 percent complication rate for fistula and stricture following urethral lengthening, one of the procedures commonly performed as part of phalloplasty, the surgery which creates a functional penis for transmasculine trans people. After her experience with Dr. Rumer, Carlie decided against a malpractice suit and tried to spread warnings about the surgeon on her own. Please don't stalk patients online?? RT @ShifterofShapes: Dr Kathy Rumer is another "sex reassignment surgeon" who botched countless patients and gave many colostomy bags along with other life long complications. Hannah Simpson, a 34-year-old trans woman from New York City, says that two weeks after she had GRS with Dr. Rumer in the summer of 2014, she noticed that her vulva was starting to look asymmetrical, with one part looking red and swollen. Basically two steps forward, one step back, says former WPATH president and current communications director Jamison Green of the explosion in surgical growth. Thanks for other patients' medical records too. According to the complaint, the defendants performed male-to-female gender reassignment surgery, a bilateral augmentation and related surgical procedures on Minto on July 12, 2016. Some worry about anti-transition media crusaders leveraging trans medical horror stories into political opposition against transitioning itself, since 2016 has focused exclusively on trans patients. Still, such procedures are expensive: It can cost around $25,000 for a vaginoplasty. Missed the final consultations of the season? Download PDF. Its the insurance system, its the way people get paid. Joelle Trieste, PhD on Twitter: "RT @ShifterofShapes: Dr Kathy Rumer Teri Rumer called me to cancel the surgery because I didn't weigh enough. Simpson, who was studying medicine at the time, described her new vulva: a misshaped clitoris that was off to the side and a labia that looked more like a lump than two flaps. Simpson experienced other complications as well, including hair inside her vaginal canal that the surgeon had promised to remove, as well as odd placement of her urethra. Creepy. Google: delaware-valley-aesthetics-pllc-v-john-doe. We now have urologists, gynecologists, and micro-surgeons of all kinds who are involved in genital reconstruction. The details of the arbitration proceedings and their outcomes are not public; none of the plaintiffs in the cases against Dr. Rumers practice returned multiple requests for an interview. Kathy is history. My roommate and I both have had surgery with Dr. Rumer. Most of her patients including the defendants in an ongoing case are low income an Marci however just so happens to have the power to drop Rumer from WPATH. Phone: (855) 782-5665. Scan this QR code to download the app now, https://jezebel.com/when-surgeons-fail-their-trans-patients-1844774990. Dr. Kathy Rumer - Experienced Gender Surgeon in Philadelphia Since 2016 the blog has intermittently posted figures in Guy Fawkes masks, the doctors home address, and linked to public reports about the surgeons work. Dr. Kathy L. Rumer is trusted by her patients for ethical, high quality care. Our goal, of course, is to train more people so that at least in major areas people dont have to travel So theres also that lag time between getting people trained appropriately and getting institution centers [and] hospitals up and running., Cutting down on that lag time to meet the growing demand for gender-affirming surgeries can often mean cutting valuable training corners for hospitals and surgeons. Cookie Notice Kathy Rumer did not reach this point of zero accountability without help. In one case, according to a pre-trial memo, attorneys intended to bring Dr. Jess Ting, a surgeon and medical school professor specializing in GRS at Mt. Top and Bottom and no butchering. Generally, it results in a loss of tissue in the infected area. One of the ways we create uniform standards has to be an open exchange of ideas, says Dr. Ting, of Mt. My symptons and complaints are WELL-DOCUMENTED in all of my emails to Dr. Rumer's office. According to the report, surgeons offering gender-affirming surgeries should undergo extensive training, including seminar, office, practical, and aftercare sessions, as well as ongoing continuing education. I'm a 35-yr old trans-woman. It's a baby-sized vagina/wound. Dr. Rumer is a leading aesthetic & reconstructive plastic surgeon who specializes in Gender Reassignment Surgery. She has now consulted with, by her own count, 36 surgeons about fixing her genitalia. Most trans people were forced to pay for surgeries out of pocket until 2014, when the Obama administration restored coverage of gender-affirming surgeries on Medicare and instituted a ban on insurance exclusions of transition surgeries in 2016. Jul 12, 2018. She told me that it's very rare for someone to develop granulation tissue like this a year after bottom surgery. People will always make the choice of fast and cheap over good in some cases, he added more recently. That seems like her go-to word for every check-up: "beautiful." In July 2018, I had minor surgery right in her office to remove some granulation tissue. Non-profit organizations like WPATH have traditionally tried to fill the need for training but lack the capacity to institute systemic changes on their own. This is a great one to share. In finding a doctor to perform a surgery prospective patients like Carlie are largely on their own. Each of those disciplines have separate boards responsible for certification. Despite Dr. Rumers insistence that everything was fine Simpson developed necrosis of the vulva. Share this post! I'm not ok! When Surgeons Fail Their Trans Patients - Jezebel (Attachments: # 1 Case Management Track Form, # 2 Civil Cover Sheet, # 3 Designation Form) (jwl, ) (Entered: 03/20/2018) Main Doc ument. Advocates describe a patchwork of surgical practices and transgender centers for excellence overseen by local hospitals and state medical boards. The Mazzoni Center: Kathy Rumer has made generous donations to the Mazzoni Center in the past who remained completely silent in response to a petition to them for a public statement denouncing Rumers litigious SLAPP suit against her own patients. Until the powerful grow the spine to finally speak up the onus falls upon us to be the vanguard and defend our community from Rumer. . The Newsletter Bringing the Legal System to Light. The answer: It is up to us to hold Rumer and all of the people who protect her accountable. Rule 5: This sub is by and for trans people. I endured months of intense physical therapy and very uncomfortable tests to prepare for revision surgery. That took away my agency, changing around my story like that.. PHILADELPHIA A patient is suing Dr. Kathy Rumer and Delaware Valley Aesthetics PLLC, which does business as Rumer Cosmetic Surgery, citing alleged medical negligence. Her office accepts new patients. But no board has wanted to take this on.. Dr. Rumers attorney, Lance Rogers, wrote in a status report on July 31 that his office had additionally subpoenaed Google, CloudFlarean internet service providerand an unnamed domain registration site to gain access to the identity of the anonymous blogger, as well as retain the services of an expert in advanced investigative computer techniques. The case remains pending. In addition to performing hundreds of gender-affirming procedures each year, Dr. Rumer also directs a 1-year . It seems likely Dr. Rumer would say, as she writes on her website and argued in court, that these complications are the result of poor adherence to her offices postoperative directions, or are part of the reasonable risk of any surgery of this kind. I hope you can appreciate that from our perspective, these facts understandably lead to questions about the integrity of your inquiry and article. (By the time I reached out to Rumer for comment, we had been working on versions of this story intermittently for over a year, and the we was clearly meant to refer to the reporter and Jezebel together, as is common practice.). There is no independent resource where patients can get data on a surgeons complication rate. These are . The letter, which contained the corroborated accounts of several conference attendees, called into question the accuracy of Dr. Rumers miraculous claim. This was my first Reddit post from what was really intended to be an anonymous account. For more information, please see our But the people who are not satisfied with their surgeries, at the hands of Dr. Rumer or others, have found it difficult to have their complaints meaningfully addressed. (Like Alexis Lake, these guys are also deserving of some free publicity.) We would mostly suggest putting pressure on Sultan Shakir, the sitting president of Mazzoni, We highly recommend calling the health center despite this. I've been in psychotherapy for many months because I basically received a sexual trauma instead of proper surgery with appropriate aftercare. Dr. Rumer's office literally told me to just do the best I can and iodine-douche every 2 days. While insurance coverage for GRS has benefited countless lives, an unintentional side effect has been what Dr. Marci Bowers, a San Francisco-based gender surgeon who has been practicing for three decades, refers to as a culture of permissiveness: As far as an insurance company goes, if the patient survived the operation, leaves the hospital in a prescribed amount of time, and doesnt die of some hideous complication or is not readmitted multiple times, she says, that is their measure of success. Providers like Dr. Rumer, she says, understand the industry and sign contracts to become preferred providers, effectively funnelling new patients into their practice based on these metrics. Any association with this doctor deserves to be career ending and we need to make it a statement that anyone who aids and abets Rumer is to be heckled and shamed. Ardmore, PA 19003. It kept accruing secretions and urine and got really smelly and I was scared of the thing for like the first year, they say, until I figured out there wasnt supposed to be hair there.. Give her some free publicity). Bottom surgery for both transfeminine and transmasculine people is multidisciplinary in nature, requiring plastic surgical, urological, and gynecological experience. "You can have permanent redness of the nose and, if the undermining of the soft tissue is too severe, you can have skin death. If you have any questions, or would like to setup a phone, Skype or in-person consultation with Dr. Rumer, please send us a message using the form below. (855) 782-5665. When a person in attendance confronted her about the images, she allegedly replied, you have a good memory, have a nice day. After a nine-month investigation, the medical board determined that the circumstances, in this case, do not permit formal prosecution, as per a response to the complaint shared with Jezebel. Dr. Kathy Rumer Accused of Abusing Transgender Patients They've had so many problems processing the correct procedures codes, dates, etc. PHILADELPHIA A patient is suing Dr. Kathy Rumer and Delaware Valley Aesthetics PLLC, which does business as Rumer Cosmetic Surgery, citing alleged medical negligence. Can't keep records straight. I'm getting gross green discharge. Dr. Kathy Rumer has 2 locations. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Patients have also reported being misgendered by her staff. NYS Gov. Kathy Hochul dumps toxic Colorado political guru Adam Sullivan In addition to performing hundreds of gender-affirming procedures each year, Dr. Rumer also directs a 1-year . When you see a pattern of outcomes that suggests that maybe a surgeon isnt meeting standards of care, then you feel obliged to speak up.. I kept insisting to them that I couldn't wait that long. I SHOULD HAVE HAD THIS WHEN THE DOCTOR ORIGINALLY TOLD ME OVER A YEAR AGO. ALBANY - A political guru recently exposed as a main adviser to Gov. For more information, please see our As a result, only a handful of specialists in the U.S. even offered bottom surgery in the first place, catering to a narrow pool of patients who could actually afford the procedure. TALK TO A REALSELF ADVISOR. In May 2018, 192 post-op trans patients penned an open letter to WPATH laying out several concerns about the current system, among them that surgeons were offering free or low-cost surgeries to under-resourced patients in order to gain operating experience in procedures for which they have incomplete professional training, falsifying complication rates in preoperative counseling, academic publishing, and public presentations, providing experimental surgeries without informed consent, presenting inaccurate medical information to patients, and providing insufficient aftercare for patients. We can beat Rumer through a war of attrition by denying her as many new patients as possible. For more information, please see our Dr. Kathy Rumer, DO | Ardmore, PA | Family Medicine | Vitals
Pure Capitalism Is An Economic System Characterized By, Articles K